How to Recognize a Drowning Person: Knowledge That Saves Lives

Most people sincerely believe that they will be able to recognize a drowning person if they are nearby. They imagine cries, splashes, and flailing arms, as seen in movies. In reality, the situation looks quite different. A drowning person often looks as if they are just trying to stay afloat. They do not scream, wave, or attract attention. It is this silence that makes drowning one of the most cunning causes of death. The ability to recognize a drowning person is a skill that can save lives. And it does not require special preparation, only attention and knowledge of a few key signs.

The Main Myth: Drowning People Cry Out

Let's start with the most dangerous misconception. In Hollywood movies, drowning people always loudly call for help, wave their arms, and beat at the water. In reality, it's the opposite. When a person drowns, their body automatically switches to survival mode. They cannot scream because their respiratory system is blocked: each breath is so difficult to take. The vocal cords cannot produce sound because all attention is focused on trying to swallow air. The person does not wave their arms; instead, they reflexively pull them to their sides, trying to push themselves out of the water. There are no rhythmic movements; there are only chaotic, sharp jerks.

Therefore, if you see someone in the water who is silent, looking at one point, their body is almost vertical, and their arms seem glued to their torso, this is not a game. This is an instinctive reaction of a drowning person. It lasts from 20 to 60 seconds. And it is during these seconds that the person's survival is decided.

The Instinctive Reaction of a Drowning Person: What It Is and How It Looks

The term \"instinctive reaction of a drowning person\" was introduced by Dr. Francesco Pia in the 1970s. He described a series of signs by which one can unambiguously identify a person who physically cannot call for help. Here are the key ones:

• Silence. The person does not scream or talk. All their strength goes into keeping their mouth above water.
• No movement of arms above water. Instead of waving, the arms go under water or are at shoulder level. They make chaotic, \"sculling\" movements that do not create momentum.
• Vertical position of the body. The person does not lie on the water, nor do they swim — they stand in the water almost vertically, as if trying to stand on tiptoes.
• Reversed head. In an attempt to breathe, the person tilts their head back and opens their mouth.
• Loss of focus of gaze. The eyes are either closed or glassy, the pupils are dilated, the gaze is \"nowhere\".
• Change of breathing. Before going under water, the person may make several gasping breaths with a characteristic \"squeak\". These are the last attempts to swallow air.

If you notice any of these signs, do not wait. Time is working against you. You have no more than a minute to intervene.

What Distinguishes a Drowning Person from a Fatigued Swimmer

It is important not to confuse a drowning person with someone who is simply tired or resting. A fatigued swimmer usually stays on the surface horizontally, their movements are rhythmic and purposeful. They can breathe calmly, talk, and ask for help. A drowning person, however, cannot talk; their movements are uncoordinated, they do not control their body. They try, but cannot move towards the shore or a boat.

Another distinguishing feature: a fatigued swimmer can swim with their head up or flip over on their back. A drowning person is almost always in a vertical position, their face and head barely holding above water. If you are unsure, ask the question: \"Do you need help?\". If the person is conscious, they can at least nod or exhale a word. If they do not respond or look at you with a blank expression, this is a dangerous signal.

Especially attentive to children. Children can drown silently and quickly. They can go under water in 20 seconds in front of parents who have just turned away for a moment. It is important not only to know the signs but also to constantly observe children in the water.

Physiology of Drowning: Why We Can't Cry Out

To understand why a drowning person is silent, you need to look at the physiology. When water enters the respiratory tract, laryngospasm begins — a reflexive contraction of the glottis. This is a protective mechanism that prevents water from entering the lungs. But it also blocks the ability to make sounds. The person cannot breathe in, cannot breathe out, cannot call for help.

At the same time, the body switches to \"economic mode\". Oxygen is consumed only by vital organs — the brain and heart. The limbs receive the least amount of energy, so movements become weak and clumsy. The person cannot control their hands; they simply try to push their body to the surface. This lasts until oxygen runs out, and then consciousness is lost.

Important: drowning does not always involve a person hiding under water. They may be on the surface, but already unable to save themselves. Therefore, do not wait until they go under water — you may be too late.

What to Do: Algorithm for a Bystander

If you suspect that someone is drowning, act immediately and decisively. Your action plan should be clear:

1. Cry out \"Help!\" to attract the attention of those around you. If there are lifeguards nearby, let them come over. 2. If you cannot swim, do not try to reach the drowning person yourself. Find something floating (a ring, a board, an empty bottle) and throw it so that the person can grab it. Use a stick, rope, or clothing to pull them out. 3. If you can swim and are confident in your abilities, approach the drowning person from behind. Never approach from the front — in panic, they may grab you and pull you under water. Take them by the chin, holding their head above water, and swim to the shore. 4. After pulling them out of the water, check their breathing and pulse. If there is none, start CPR (artificial respiration and chest compressions) and call an ambulance.

Prevention — The Best Rescue

Knowing how to recognize a drowning person does not replace the basic rules of water safety. Always choose equipped beaches for swimming where there are lifeguards. Do not swim beyond the buoys. Do not leave children unsupervised. Do not swim while intoxicated. And if you see someone acting strangely in the water, do not dismiss it — go up and ask if everything is alright. This may be the very question that saves a life.

Remember: a drowning person often looks as if they are just trying to swim. They are not heard, they do not call for help. The only way to know them is to be attentive. And if you remember the signs of the instinctive reaction of a drowning person, you will be able to come to their aid in time. And that is the most important thing.
© libmonster.com

Permanent link to this publication: